Tried and true will reward you

Old-fashioned garden plants

By Amy McDowell

“I’d like to plant some low perennials over here in the shade,” my neighbor said, “but I don’t want any hostas. They’re too old-fashioned—like something my mother and her generation would plant.” Raising my eyebrows, I stammered for a couple of minutes before regaining my composure and coming up with a list of shade perennials for her.

Trends in plant popularity are puzzling. What makes some plants “in” and others “old fashioned”? Hostas are gems in the shade garden and it’s hard to imagine casting them aside as old fashioned. There are countless plants beloved by earlier generations that deserve space in our gardens today.

Twiggy old Hydrangeas (H. arborescens or paniculata) with cantaloupe-sized clusters of blooms are robust, reliable and trouble-free. Along the shady north side of a home or underneath the dense canopy of trees, Hydrangeas bloom faithfully and sucker to form a wide mound. Newer varieties are terrific, but their ancestors shouldn’t be forgotten.

Hedgerows of bridal wreath Spirea (Spiraea x vanhoutei) still frame the back yards of homes in some historic early 1900s Des Moines neighborhoods. Draped with tiny white blooms along graceful arching stems each spring, Spirea are pest-free and easy to love. Straggly in shade but dense and showy in sun, bridal wreath Spirea is great for a privacy planting around a patio.

Just as we disregard some delightful old garden plants, we sometimes trip over our own feet in a rush to snatch up the newest garden center offering. Unproven in our climate, the newest plants on the market can lead to failure and frustration. Daphne ‘Carol Macki’ (D. x burkwoodii), a darling shrub with fragrant white blooms, raged the Des Moines market a dozen years ago. Everyone planted them, and over the winter nearly everyone lost them. Daphne’s popularity fizzled out in a few years, after local gardeners realized she was a no-go for this area.

Every season, plant breeders, growers and garden centers offer new selections. Some become raging successes and some fail. Like anything new on the market, there’s always the possibility you’re buying a lemon. The plants of yesteryear, however, are tried and true and worth consideration anew.